In Defense of Farmer Boy
I’ve been noticing a disturbing theme lately among my blog friends, which is that while you adore the Little House books, some have not bothered to read Farmer Boy. The impression I get (mistaken or not) is that you love Laura, and want to know her story, so why take time out for boring ass Almonzo.
I could not disagree more. Do not get me wrong, I love Laura. I love her temper and her tiny rebellions and learning about life on the prairie. I love Mary and Carrie and Jack and Ma and Pa and Pet and Patty and all of it. But gosh they were poor, they were always moving, the crops were always failing (did they ever get a single good crop? I honestly do not think so), Pa dressed up in blackface, and Ma hated Indians. What if you could have a cozy book that told of this time gone by, without all of that baggage? Enter Farmer Boy.

Farmer Boy tells the story of a year in the life of Laura’s future husband, Almonzo, beginning just before his 9th birthday, when he’s living on his parents’ prosperous farm in Malone, New York, close to the Canadian border.
The Wilder family is well off and respected. They breed the best horses in the state, his mother makes the best butter, which is shipped all the way to New York City for fancy people to eat. They have huge barns to house their horses and cattle, which are still not big enough to contain their riches, so some cattle have to sleep outside.
Farm life is hard, though. They work hard, from before the sun comes up until after the sun goes down. Mother makes most of their clothing from wool from sheep they raise. It is fun to read about the sheep shearing, and to learn how Mother dyes her own wool. A cobbler comes once a year and makes/repairs shoes. A tin peddler comes and sells them pots and pans if they need them. The kids walk to school in the dark, trudging through snow, and come home in the dark, trudging through snow. The teacher spends a week or two with each family in the district, and then the school year is over. Attendance is spotty for farm kids, who are often needed at home more than in the classroom.
Almonzo’s father has given him two young oxen to train, and pretty much leaves him to figure it out on his own. Huge blocks of ice are cut from the river in the winter, and stored in the ice house packed in sawdust to get them through the summer. If they want cake and ice cream, they start from scratch and make the cake and the ice cream. They grow practically everything they eat.
My mom bought me the Little House books when I was 9, and I started with Farmer Boy, because she told me of his absolute love for horses. There is mention of one of the horses from Farmer Boy in These Happy Golden Years, when Laura and Almonzo are getting to know each other.
My advice, then, is to go ahead. Love Laura. She is the protagonist of the series and her story is fascinating and so well told. But when you finish her books, give Almonzo’s story a chance. It’s the cozy read you might just need after all of the harrowing adventures from the prairie.
8 Comments
Jamie
There are lots of things I love about Farmer Boy (the food! the ending!), but I found it troubling as a kid. The bullwhip scene made me especially queasy, but also the way Eliza Jane talks to her mother when she comes back home. And how about the scene where they’re trying desperately to save a crop before the sun comes up? That one doesn’t really make sense to me as an adult but I found it harrowing as a chid.
I think as a kid I found Almanzo’s father worrying, because he seemed so stern and distant. Also as a kid I found Laura’s father appealing, because she so obviously adored him. But as an adult I have to say I’d rather deal with Almanzo’s dad than Laura’s dad!
J
The bullwhip scene is a LOT. I was thinking about it last night actually, and how inappropriate it might be for some kids. But I mean, those kids KILLED a man, and were planning similar stuff, so maybe?
Yeah, Almonzo’s parents were definitely more strict than Laura’s. But he had an easier life. And that ending!
Elisabeth
I really liked Farmer Boy. The only book in that series I really struggle with in The Long Winter. BLEAK!!! And it was even bleaker and more horrible in reality.
J
The Long Winter is SO BLEAK, and yes, I’ve read about the reality and how much worse it was for the family. I cannot imagine.
Hannah Frey
You have inspired me to reread Farmer Boy, and I shall have to do so. As a kid, I loved Laura so much, that yes, I didn’t want to read Farmer Boy because it wasn’t about her. I’m sure I read it at least once, but maybe only once, which for a childhood book was very rare, usually I read and reread and reread books.
J
Oh, I hope you enjoy it this time around!
NGS
For years I thought I hated historical fiction. And, for the most part, it is one of my least favorite genres. But you know why I thought I hated ALL of it? Because of the Little House books and Sarah, Plain and Tall. Why is everyone out there suggesting these are good books? Nothing ever happens except people are cold and hungry and Pa bosses everyone around? WHY? This might be my second hottest book take after Tolkien books are boring.
J
LOL, well if you don’t like those, you likely won’t like this one, though no one is ever starving or in danger of freezing, so there’s that. But not much happens other than life on a farm in upstate New York.